March 1, 2008: A part of the world largely ignored by
U.S. news media since the end of NATO’s Balkan engagement
in 1999, Kosovo has resurfaced in U.S. news in the last two
weeks. Kosovo’s unilateral declaration of independence
and a demonstration in Belgrade that turned violent with the
burning of the U.S. embassy made headlines. The United States
was among the first countries to recognize Kosovo. Since Russia
is Serbia’s strongest supporter and Kosovo’s
independence would end Serbian sovereignty in the disputed
province, U.S. media – with their usual inward focus
– speculate on the effect that an independent Kosovo will
have on U.S.-Russian relations.
In reality, the aftermath of Kosovo's declaration of
independence has greater importance for the European Union and
for relations between the European Union and Russia. To date a
total of 21 countries have officially recognized Kosovo, among
them the United States and Switzerland. However, the European
Union has 27 members, and only ten of them are among the 21
countries having recognized Kosovo. Seven EU countries have
declared that they will not recognize Kosovo anytime soon. In a
statement immediately following Kosovo’s declaration of
independence, the European Union was unable to reach agreement
on a common approach to the new situation. Instead, the EU says
it will be up to individual member states to decide whether to
recognize the new self-proclaimed republic. The "Union" of
Europe is again divided on foreign policy.
In December 2007, EU leaders met in Lisbon to sign a treaty
outlining a new administrative structure for the European
Union. The agreement was declared a major breakthrough,
including among its provisions the eventual scrapping of the
unanimity principle for most EU decisions and the introduction
of a European Union foreign minister, who will supposedly speak
for the European Union on foreign affairs.
The inability of EU members to agree today on a common
response to Kosovo’s declaration of independence shows
that having a foreign minister in the future can only be a
farce. The European Union has never had a consistent common
foreign policy, and it won’t in the coming years, either.
The reason? All EU members would have to give up their national
sovereignty in foreign policy matters, and that isn't about to
happen. What is more likely is a "core Europe" made up of a
smaller group of EU members willing to move toward full
political union, including a common foreign policy. The
"core Europe" concept also coincides with Bible prophecies
of a union of ten kings in a final resurrection of the Roman
Empire.
Although Russia’s dismay over the Kosovo situation may
now be largely directed at the United States, Russia’s
relations with the European Union will not be enhanced by the
EU’s involvement in Kosovo. Even though EU members were
unable to agree on a joint declaration recognizing Kosovo as an
independent country, the day before Kosovo's declaration of
independence they did agree to provide additional police
security and legal experts to strengthen the "rule of law" in
Kosovo. The EU will send 2000 personnel – mostly police
officers – to Kosovo. However, since the administration
of Kosovo is under United Nations authority, Russia and Serbia
consider the EU move to be illegal. According to Russia,
without a corresponding UN Security Council resolution,
Kosovo's independence is a violation of Serbia's sovereignty.
The long-term effect of Serbia's relationship with the EU
remains to be seen, but the EU's action will not mean any
movement toward EU membership for Serbia anytime soon.
As a side note, France and Germany were among the first
countries to recognize Kosovo. Oddly enough, their quick action
on recognition is seen by some observers as hypocrisy based on
their condemnation of America's military action against Sadam
Hussein five years ago. Their position then was based on the
lack of UN legitimization via the UN Security Council. Without
international legitimization, sovereign borders may not be
altered – a principle of international law that France
and Germany seem to have forgotten in the last five years.