April 20, 2011: Hungary's new constitution has raised
eyebrows among activist groups that support same-sex marriage
and abortion. However, the provisions drawing the ire of
activists are supported by recent decisions of the European
Court of Human Rights (ECHR). About one month after the
proposed constitution was released to the public, the Hungarian
parliament approved the proposal on April 18, 2011 by a vote of
262 to 44, with 1 abstention. The document will take effect on
January 1, 2012.
The new constitution includes the right to life for the
fetus from the moment of conception. "Human dignity is
inviolable," the text states. "Everyone has the right to life
and human dignity; the life of a fetus will be protected from
conception." Abortionist groups claim that the wording could
lead to efforts to overturn Hungary's abortion law and result
in restrictions on abortion. However, on December 16, 2010 the
ECHR ruled in the case A. B. C. v. Ireland that there is
no right to abortion in the European Convention and that the
restriction on abortion in Ireland "was based on profound moral
values concerning the nature of life."
The constitution also incurred the wrath of activitists by
limiting the definition of marriage as being between a man and
a woman, implying that a family based on marriage is the only
type protected by the state: "Hungary protects the institution
of marriage between man and woman, a matrimonial relationship
voluntarily established, as well as the family as the basis for
the survival of the nation. Hungary supports child-bearing."
Here again the ECHR supports the new constitution. In its
judgment rendered on June 24, 2010 in the case Schalk and
Kopf v. Austria, the Court declared that "States are still
free . . . to restrict access to marriage to
different-sex couples" (§108).
Members of Hungary's ruling party Fidesz, which currently
holds a two-thirds majority in Parliament, are convinced that
the new constitution completes the transition from communism to
democracy. The current Hungarian constitution dates from 1949
but was significantly amended in 1989 following the collapse of
communism.
The most notable aspect of Hungary's new constitution is its
aim to safeguard "the intellectual and spiritual unity of [the
Hungarian] nation." That "spiritual unity" is based on
Christianity. The document refers to Christianity and to
"Christian Europe" in its preamble and it promotes cooperation
between the State and the churches for the common good of the
society. Interestingly, Hungary is one of the countries that
supported Italy in its crucifix appeal at the ECHR. The
Hungarian government declared then that the crucifix must be
respected as an organic component of the Italian culture and
identity. According to Vatican statistics, 59 percent of the
ten million people living in Hungary are Roman Catholic.